Where Are Portable Toilets on City Streets?


Good morning.

(Want to get California Today delivered to your inbox? Here’s the sign-up.)

This morning, we have the latest dispatch from Marie Tae McDermott, in our series answering readers’ questions about inequality in California:

Patricia Dunn, a reader in Sonoma wrote: “I have witnessed open urination in San Francisco on the public streets and wonder why portable toilets at minimum are not on city streets.”

We’ve heard from residents about sidestepping human waste on their way to work, and some, including Ms. Dunn, have wondered why there aren’t more portable toilets.

A 2017 report by the city of Los Angeles on the state of toilets on Skid Row found that there were just nine public toilets available for its 1,964 homeless residents. By contrast, the United Nations’s standard for refugee camps requires there to be one toilet for every 20 people.

When there is a lack of public toilets, as there is in California, people are forced to relieve themselves elsewhere. Sidewalks become a breeding ground for infectious diseases.

“It really is a human rights issue,” said the Rev. Andrew Bales, of Union Rescue Mission, about the current state of sanitation on Skid Row. In 2014, Mr. Bales had an open wound that came into contact with human waste while he was conducting homeless outreach. The wound became infected with flesh-eating bacteria and as a result, his leg was amputated in 2016.

[Read more about how to help the homeless.]

Mr. Bales estimates that the population of Skid Row has swelled to around 2,800 people and the number of toilets is still lacking. The shelter he heads recently added 11 toilets for 120 women to use.

“It really is a health hazard, especially for people living on the streets,” Mr. Bales said.

In addition, many homeless people are hesitant to use existing public toilets and portable toilets because they pose risks. The 2017 report illustrated how people are afraid of being robbed or attacked in restrooms at night. Some toilets lack locks or even doors. In San Diego, one 24-hour restroom was removed after it became a public nuisance.

In efforts to mitigate the health hazard caused by human waste on the streets, the cities of San Francisco and Los Angeles started public toilet programs.

Facilities are maintained by paid attendants who make sure restrooms are clean and safe for people to use.

Mr. Bales thinks these attendants are key to the success of the programs. Although their jobs are to monitor the facilities, they are often the first people to respond to and prevent fatal drug overdoses and to intercept crime.

Since implementing the program in 2014, San Francisco has seen a decrease in requests related to cleaning human waste from the street. There are now 24 facilities throughout the city. The city recently announced that it will keep three restrooms, called Pit Stops, open all day, every day because of the growing demand.

“This is not complicated — when people have access to a clean, safe restroom, they will use it,” Mayor London Breed said in a statement.

Restrooms don’t have to be mobilized to be effective. A report found that adding an attendant to an existing underutilized restroom in L.A. resulted in an increase of daily uses, to 80 from 30, in the first four months.

In L.A., a single Pit Stop site, which includes toilets, a hand-washing station and an attendant costs $339,000 a year.

The idea behind the newsroom, she said, is to “really promote stories by people who are directly impacted by giving them sort of editorial support, helping them to write the stories about the larger issues.”

The “Right to Home” project brought together collaborators who work with street publications around the country, including Berkeley’s Street Spirit.

In one piece, Justin Jones, who grew up in Berkeley, wrote about navigating school and life as he moved from place to place. He described what it was like to set out on his own after growing up without a stable place to call home.

“The reality is that many young people are fighting the conditions of homelessness when we’re still works in progress,” he wrote.

[Read the full story here.]

We often link to sites that limit access for nonsubscribers. We appreciate your reading Times coverage, but we also encourage you to support local news if you can.

  • While California is spending $187 million to try to ensure an accurate count of its population in the 2020 census, Texas is spending nothing. Here’s why. [The New York Times]

  • Gov. Gavin Newsom on Friday rejected Pacific Gas & Electric’s restructuring plan. It’s the latest hurdle for the utility, as it tries to resolve its bankruptcy and a litany of other legal and financial problems. [The New York Times]

    If you missed it, get caught up on what’s ahead for PG&E. [The New York Times]

  • And as the year comes to an end, Mr. Newsom took stock of his first year in office, including his battles with the president and the “stretch” goal of building 3.5 million homes. [USA Today]

Also, here’s a look at Mr. Newsom’s big goals — and the associated risks. [The New York Times]

  • All the Democratic presidential candidates who have qualified for this Thursday’s debate at Loyola Marymount University in Los Angeles are threatening to boycott the event as members of a union representing food service employees negotiate with the university’s provider, a company called Sodexo. [The New York Times]

  • Senator Bernie Sanders retracted his endorsement of Cenk Uygur, a progressive talk show host running for the congressional seat vacated by Katie Hill. Mr. Sanders’s endorsement led to a backlash because Mr. Uygur has a long history of making offensive comments about women, Jews, Muslims and other groups. [The New York Times]

California Today goes live at 6:30 a.m. Pacific time weekdays. Tell us what you want to see: CAtoday@nytimes.com. Were you forwarded this email? Sign up for California Today here.

Jill Cowan grew up in Orange County, graduated from U.C. Berkeley and has reported all over the state, including the Bay Area, Bakersfield and Los Angeles — but she always wants to see more. Follow along here or on Twitter, @jillcowan.

California Today is edited by Julie Bloom, who grew up in Los Angeles and graduated from U.C. Berkeley.

Source link